The Cookie Plug
$2.49
411 - The Inside Scoop
Foursome Tip (4 Stuffed Cookies)
4 x 411 Stuffed Phatties brings together the ultimate stuffed cookie experience. Choose any 4 of our signature 411 cookies—Dubai, Biggie, Windmill Razz, Hood Crisp, or Onyx Slam—for a flavor-packed, limited-edition treat. Dubai Cookie: Creamy pistachio-stuffed cookie with a crunchy layer of golden Kataifi. Biggie: Peanut butter cookie filled with banana cream and drizzled with rich Nutella. Windmill Razz: Cookie butter base finished with sweet cookie butter and raspberry cheesecake. Hood Crisp: Stuffed with smooth apple pie filling, topped with apple butter and a butterscotch drizzle. Onyx Slam: Stuffed with creamy fudge filling, topped with rich, crunchy Oreos, and spooky Halloween fruit snacks! Each cookie is soft, thick, chewy, and perfectly baked for maximum indulgence. Perfect for sharing or savoring on your own, this limited-edition assortment is a must-try for stuffed cookie lovers before it’s gone.
Dubai Chocolate Cookie (Filled)
Introducing the Dubai Filled Cookie—a flavor-packed creation that’s anything but ordinary. This thicc cookie is filled with creamy pistachio and finished with a crunch of golden kataifi. It’s rich, nutty, and straight-up unforgettable. Available only at Cookie Plug and only while it’s in stock… so don’t sleep on it.
Biggie (Peanut Butter cookie filled with banana cream, drizzled in Nutella)
Say hello to the heavyweight champ—Biggie. This peanut butter cookie ain’t playin’ around, stuffed with smooth banana filling that brings the creaminess in every bite. We hit it with a Nutella drizzle for that chocolate-hazelnut flex, then crown it with a strawberry on top, because this cookie deserves the spotlight. It’s rich, it’s layered, and it’s built like a track full of bangers. One bite and you’ll know—Biggie’s not just a cookie, it’s a whole vibe.
Windmill Razz (cookie butter topped with raspberry cheesecake)
Say hello to the Windmill Razz, our limited-edition stuffed cookie that’s here to blow your mind. Each cookie is topped with raspberry cheesecake filling and Biscoff cookie butter, bringing you a crave-worthy combo of sweet, creamy, and cookie-spiced goodness. Crafted with our signature thick dough, this flavor delivers the perfect balance of rich cheesecake, fruity raspberry, and that famous Biscoff cookie spread you know and love. This one’s part of our Secret Stash—which means it won’t be around forever. Grab it while it lasts!
Hood Crisp
Dive into Cookie Plug’s Hood Crisp, the ultimate apple pie stuffed cookie that’s redefining fall vibes. Our signature Oh Snap dough—chewy, golden, and straight-up perfect—wraps around a luscious, smooth apple pie filling packed with warm, autumnal spice. Topped with a velvety dollop of apple butter and a decadent butterscotch drizzle, these fall inspired stuffed cookies deliver a burst of sweet, tangy, and rich flavors in every bite. Crafted to capture the cozy heart of the season, Hood Crisp is a limited-time treat at select locations. Whether you’re a dessert lover or chasing a fresh spin on a classic, this apple pie stuffed cookie is your fall must-have. Grab yours now and taste the magic!
Onyx Slam
Indulge in the decadently dark delight of our Onyx Slam Dirt Cake Stuffed Cookie, a monstrously delicious treat perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth! This jumbo cookie is crafted with our signature cornholio dough, stuffed to the brim with a rich, creamy chocolate filling made from a luscious blend of yogurt, powdered sugar, crushed Oreos, and velvety chocolate fudge pudding. Each cookie is baked to golden perfection, then generously topped with more of the irresistible chocolate filling, rolled in crunchy Oreo crumbs for that extra slam of flavor. For a playful, spooky twist, we crown each cookie with vibrant Halloween fruit snacks, making it as fun to look at as it is to eat. Perfect for Halloween parties, late-night cravings, or any time you want a bold, chocolatey escape, the Onyx Slam is a treat that packs a punch. Grab yours now and experience the ultimate stuffed cookie sensation!
Pump n Roll
Pump n Roll